Comments regarding Hirt's Gardens (formerly Hirt's Greenhouse & Flowers)
Click here to return to Hirt's Gardens (formerly Hirt's Greenhouse & Flowers)'s listing.
|
Comments:
« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | ... 10 Next »
Rating | Author | Content |
Positive | sfenster (7 reviews) | On Jul 4, 2010, sfenster Pemberton, NJ wrote: I wanted a replacement male arctic beauty kiwi for one that had died - the vendor was out for the year and my female seemed lonely :-) I found an inexpensive one on eBay sold by Hirt's. The feedback there was quite positive, so I ordered. The plant arrived quickly. It was relatively small, but healthy and is thriving. |
Positive | butch222 (1 review) | On Jul 3, 2010, butch222 Lenhartsville, PA wrote: i have purchased 4 different shipments of hibiscus plants. i must say, fast shipping, and plants were as promised on their site. i am very pleased with the condition i received them in, now it is up to me to grow them, so far so good. i will reorder again and again. |
Positive | brokensandwedge (1 review) | On Jun 21, 2010, brokensandwedge Brainerd, MN wrote: I ordered 6 plants from hirtz gardens through amazon, They came fast and the plants were in great shape. |
Negative | lytkinedennis (4 reviews) | On Jun 20, 2010, lytkinedennis Staten Island, NY wrote: On there ebay store i bought a yucca and an ensete. I made a big mistake. The plants i got came quickly but were both less than the size of a penny. These quickly rotted in my well draining soil because these came right out of tissue culture and had no roots. |
Positive | normarod1 (1 review) | On Jun 17, 2010, normarod1 Searsport, ME wrote: I was surprised to read the negative reviews on this company (I had done so after placing an order). I am thrilled to report that my shipment arrived within 3 days; plants were green, healthy, and the soil was still wet in the starter pack of Jamaican Scotch bonnets. The Chocolate habanero was still moist. Yes, the plants were taped down and packed in peanuts. However, as this was my first experience with shipped seedlings, I can only say it was adequate, as my seedlings were still in the pack and/or pot, and were undamaged. Transplant went fine. I am sure that the varieties ordered were the varieties received as everything else up to this point is great! I have never received an online shipment so quickly for such a reasonable cost!!! |
Neutral | jukeb0xm0ney (1 review) | On Jun 7, 2010, jukeb0xm0ney South Windsor, CT wrote: I wish I read all this before ordering....more negative feedback than positive?? I ordered a plant and two packets of seeds. Never received one packet of seeds. The plant is questionable. Lots of holes in the leaves....seems like something has been eating it. No flowers or buds yet, not sure how it will do. The customer service is horrible. I contacted them via email as well as sending them an ebay message after ordering. I wanted to know what combined shipping was so I could send them the correct payment. No response. I called and left a message asking the same thing. No response. I finally called again (as I didn't want negative feedback on my ebay account for not paying) & got someone on the phone. |
Negative | jleigh (3 reviews) | On May 28, 2010, jleigh Ballston Lake, NY (Zone 5a) wrote: Posted on July 6, 2008, updated May 28, 2010 On May 28th, 2010, jleigh added the following: Like I stated previously, they have seeds and plants that are hard to get around here... and ship them (sometimes) quickly. However the germination rates on my last order from them was almost laughable... if I hadn't spent $2.99 for a packet of 10 tomato seeds. Customer service is difficult to deal with, and the plants I received died before the end of the season. The tomatoes I ordered didn't even flower before kicking the bucket. (The other plants, hardy geraniums and coral bells aren't hard to keep alive and I have entire flower beds full of both... no fault here.) I'd say if you are really wanting of a specific pepper/tomato plant (etc) than you can try Hirt's, just be aware you may be disappointed |
Positive | inge_formenti (3 reviews) | On May 14, 2010, inge_formenti Louisville, KY wrote: I had found these people on Amazon, but the negative feedback led me not to order. However, they were still there after a couple years, and Amazon is pretty harsh to dud vendors, so I looked at their ratings, which were pretty good. So last week I ordered some things in 3-4 inch pots. They came quickly, were nicely grown but not potbound, and were packed well (Better than a Bluestone I order I got recently). Some were hosta, which matched the variety. Everything else is, well, green! This is the second plant source this year that has sent priority mail--this seems like the way to go, as I know it can go coast to coast in three days. I would order again, through Amazon, not eBay, which has its own set of problems. Frequently when I order perennials from Bluestone, the plants are so small I put them right together in the hole. I thought I would do this with Hirt's six foxglove package, but it looks like I need to start a second patch to hold the much bigger plants! |
Negative | debles (16 reviews) | On May 4, 2010, debles Tulsa, OK wrote: Posted on April 10, 2003, updated May 4, 2010 On April 20th, 2008, debles added the following: I ordered many tomato and pepper plants from them this spring. All of them arrived healthy and strong. I was amazed that they were all in great shape because of the way they were packed, but once again I was thrilled to get heirloom plants, shipped quickly and at a decent price. On May 4th, 2010, debles changed the rating from positive to negative and added the following: Since I had good experiences in the past, I chose to order my pepper plants, some eggplant and one odd tomato plant from them this year through Ebay. Still waiting for the pepper plants but not holding my breath. The tiny eggplant seedlings and dead tomato plant arrived today. It was an orange purple smudge tomato that they charged just under $6 for plus shipping. It was lying completely dead in a box of styrofoam peanuts along with the 4-pack of eggplant seedlings. After inquiring about the pepper plants, they've assured me that they will ship them today. I ordered 4 pepper plants someplace else, just in case the ones from Hirts arrive dead like the tomato. Don't plan to purchase from them again in the future. There are too many other providers who at least make an effort to fill orders properly and pack well for shipping. |
Positive | HillBillyFarmer (1 review) | On Apr 24, 2010, HillBillyFarmer Ironbound, NJ (Zone 7a) wrote: I ordered, via Amazon, 12 of their "black" and yellow tomatoes on Wednesday. Email to me indicated they were shipped the same day. They arrived on Saturday morning in Newark, NJ. Plants in fine shape. I reused the box with the Styrofoam peanuts to send out some glassware to a friend the same day! Although I ordered these before I read some of the negative comments on here, I can say my own experience was totally satisfactory. Now let's see if my green thumb proves to follow through! |
Positive | lnw1954 (1 review) | On Apr 23, 2010, lnw1954 Chesapeake, VA wrote: I ordered plants from Hirts via Amazon, then I read the reviews and regreted placing the order after reading the negative ones. My order was placed on April 20, 2010, and I received the order today, April 23. The plants were in excellent condition. Believe me I was pleasantly surprised after reading the negative reviews. I will order again from Hirts. What a positive experience! |
Negative | IndianaGardener (7 reviews) | On Apr 7, 2010, IndianaGardener wrote: They have stolen my bristlecone bonsai photo and used it without permission on two separate occasions on multiple sales websites each time! I have even asked them not to do so. Very dishonest! No company who commits intellectual property theft should be trusted. |
Negative | InsaniD (9 reviews) | On Mar 30, 2010, InsaniD Columbia, MO wrote: We spent $86 before shipping totals and bought through their eBay store, last spring. Here are two pictues of what we recieved (you'll need to copy and paste the links in the address bar above): |
Negative | manuretea (11 reviews) | On Mar 23, 2010, manuretea Medina, OH (Zone 5b) wrote: I ordered Dr. Earths Organic Citrus Fertilizer from their Hirts Garden site. After waiting two weeks I received Espoma Citrus with a Dr. Earth's UPC sticker over the Espoma one. On Mar 23, 2010, Hirt's Gardens (formerly Hirt's Greenhouse & Flowers) responded with: "I have not worked for Hirt's Greenhouse & Flowers for over 6 years. The purchase she is referring to was actually purchased directly from Amazon.com and must be returned to them for the refund. She purchased the Espoma Citrus Food by mistake instead of the Dr. Earth Citrus Food. |
Negative | gilligansroomie (1 review) | On Mar 17, 2010, gilligansroomie Millsboro, DE wrote: Buyer Beware- I wish I would have researched her before I purchased from them. There are so many other Honest and reliable companies to work with, why choose one that is about 50/50 with good and bad feedback? Is your garden and time worth a 50/50 shot? I ordered several tomato plants from Hirt's and selected a delivery date of May 1, so that I was able to plant them when it was time. March 2, I had a box arrive to me with the plants in them, 2 MONTHS early. I was offered a refund, but only if I PAID FOR SHIPPING the plants back to them. Not my fault, should not be at my expense. Did not respond to my emails, POOR Customer Service!!! Like I said there are so many other Honest and reliable companies to work with, why choose one that is about 50/50 with good and bad feedback? Is your garden and time worth a 50/50 shot? Mine isn't. Shop elsewhere. |
Positive | ssssssss (8 reviews) | On Mar 15, 2010, ssssssss Kechi, KS wrote: I have ordered from Hirt's on Ebay for several years and have always had very good luck with their plants. The delivery service is very fast. |
Neutral | SusieR (5 reviews) | On Mar 13, 2010, SusieR Springfield, IL (Zone 6a) wrote: Note: This company is on eBay as "hirtsgardens." |
Neutral | aak (1 review) | On Mar 11, 2010, aak Pittsburgh, PA wrote: Wow, I almost ordered from this company. Thank you everyone for your feedback about the seemingly awful customer service; I surely will not order from them. |
Negative | Kelsey_grow (1 review) | On Feb 22, 2010, Kelsey_grow Mason, MI wrote: I ordered several packages of seed from Hirt's - in particular, broccoli romanesco. When the seeds sprouted, I was skeptical about having the correct seed. Well, they had mislabled the seed and it grew out to be dinosaur kale! Of course, this is a much more common and less expensive seed. I contacted the company by e-mail, and got no response. I then checked Dave's Garden (which I should have done first) and saw all the negative responses. I believe all I got was a bait-and-switch routine and in my opinion this company is dishonest. |
Negative | pwr4 (1 review) | On Jan 23, 2010, pwr4 Abington, PA (Zone 7a) wrote: I purchased a "P. lutea" from Hirts Greenhouse; I was very happy to receive it as I had lost my other plant to a fungal attack. I received that plant and it did indeed look to be P. lutea....until it flowered. The ping labeled as P. lutea is purple flowered which either means I have a super rare P. lutea (yeah right) or Hirts sent me a misidentified plant. I contacted hirts and was told to send my order and payment information along with an image of the ping in question. I submitted all the evidence and got such a short reply "Our grower assures us the plant is lutea" So fundamentally Hirts when presented with indisputable evidence will not do anything to resolve a mistake on their part. It is my suggestion all davesgardens members refrain from purchasing from Hirts. Matt Hirt is indeed a poor owner/grower/businessman and has no issues with committing what amounts to fraud - take this from someone in the Horticulture industry DO NOT buy from Hirts Greenhouse you might not get what you ordered and the quality of the plants you do receive is no where comparable to the price paid. |
Positive | anne1 (6 reviews) | On Nov 2, 2009, anne1 Malvern, PA wrote: I ordered 25 Giant Shirley Foxgoves for $34.99 at an end of season sale. Then I read the feedback at Dave's Garden and was a bit concerned with some of the negative feedback. No worries. The plants arrived just a few days after I placed my order on October 23. They were large, albeit somewhat rootbound but healthy otherwise. I wasted no time in planting them and they seem to be doing well. The only minor complaint I have is the packing: 10,000 peanuts are not necessary; crumpled up newspaper would have done the job nicely. I will definitely order from Hirt's again. |
Negative | msimonel (1 review) | On Oct 17, 2009, msimonel Ridgefield, CT wrote: I am an experienced gardener. Ordered 100 saffron crocus bulbs. Received in fall 2008. Planted. Assured excellent drainage, etc. This year 2009, no bloom! I have other types of bulbs all over the property and in raised boxes, behind fences to keep pests away etc. These are all winners year after year. Crocus - nothing. |
Positive | oneuniquelady (1 review) | On Oct 12, 2009, oneuniquelady Ocala, FL wrote: I placed an order with Hirt's on Tuesday October 6th 2009 and I received my order on Friday October 9th 2009 in excellent condition. The plants I ordered were 2 Bhut Jolokia |
Negative | xenabui (1 review) | On Sep 24, 2009, xenabui Baton Rouge, LA wrote: I had ordered a few GHOST PEPPER PLANTS online from HIRT'S. Paid with my credit card and got the plants. I had put a lot of time and effort in growing these pepper plants. A few months had gone by, my plants are starting to have peppers. But the bad thing is that I realize they were not as hot as I thought it should have been. Then I do some research and realize it was not ghost pepper they had sent me. I had called and the lady told me to send the pictures and my information straight to the owners email. Which I did. The owner respond to my email, stating that i need to send the plants back and my proof of purchase. So I reply to the email stating that i have no problem sending them there plants back but i don't have my proof of purchase because it have been at least 3-6 months long. I mean how was I suppose to know that they ship me the wrong plants and therefore I need to keep my receipt for 3 to 6 months. So i asked them if they keep there records for that long, if they think I should still have mine. In that case they should check their record for my purchase. They reply to me saying that they will not issue a refund if i don't have proof of purchase. These people are very bad business. DON'T BUY FROM THEM!!!!!!! |
Negative | tulatulip (1 review) | On Sep 7, 2009, tulatulip wrote: what is with the horrible service? when you ask a question, you are lucky to get an answer, and when you do, it is a short rude response. matt hirt should consider being a little more professional since he is representing his company with his succint and gruff replies! |
Negative | RebloominRose (1 review) | On Aug 25, 2009, RebloominRose Holbrook, AZ wrote: I bought six OSO easy roses from Hirt's. Two arrived dead--dried up!--and the others looked pretty roughed up. I contacted them and they said that I needed to take pictures. Well, I am behind the times and don't have a camera, particularly a digital one. They would not refund or make any other suggestions without pictures. I feel that their customer service really is awful. Basically they called me a liar. Never will I buy from them again! |
Negative | habanero500 (1 review) | On Aug 13, 2009, habanero500 Spring Valley, CA wrote: I have many friends who like to grow chiles. This past growing season I have had 4 people contact me to identify their plants. All of the plants were not the species they were supposed to be. All of them were purchased from Hirts through E Bay. I already got the wrong plants from them myself this year. They sold me 4 Bonda Ma Jaques habanero plants that were not Bonda Ma Jaques. I did get a refund. But now I fear my 12 Chocolate Bhut Jolokia plants are not what they are. I still have to wait to see pepper pods. My friend on the east Coast bought the same plants and they are all another species. I talked with a woman from Illinois who tried twice to get Scotch Bonnet and both times got the wrong plants. Another man from Ohio purchased Bhut Jolokia that is not Bhut Jolokia and my friend from LA also now has discovered she has the wrong plants. So far I am the only one that got a refund. Hirts refuses to give a refund to these others. They swear they have the correct seed. But what kind of nursery makes this many errors!!! I truly believe they do not have the correct chile pepper seed and know it. They count on the E Bay transaction being too old, because it will take awhile before your chile plants bear fruit. So if my 12 Chocolate Bhut Jolokia plants turn out to be something else I will sue them. I sell rare chiles for high dollar so I have the right to sue them for wasting my time. So if you are mad here is another thing you can do. Most states require Agricultural paperwork to ship live plants. Find out if this applies to your state. If so report them. The fines they will pay will be far more than the money they make by not making a refund!!! |
Positive | obliqua (17 reviews) | On Jul 1, 2009, obliqua Pittsburgh, PA wrote: I have had a number of plants ordered from Hirt's. Tomato and pepper plants, a tree peony,and two oriental poppies. All arrived quickly, in great condition. The prices were great and the plants are growing and thriving. |
Positive | MagdaOR (1 review) | On Jun 22, 2009, MagdaOR Hillsboro, OR wrote: I was late on starting my tomatoes this year, so I decided to try to order starts online. Was looking for a particular heirloom tomato that was my favorite of last summer, and I found it online at Hirt's at a pretty good price. |
Negative | midrashist (3 reviews) | On Jun 8, 2009, midrashist Philadelphia, PA wrote: I ordered roughly three hundred dollars of plants this spring thru ebay. They were shipped immediately. Most of the plants arrived looking o.k. |
Negative | jvhagerman (1 review) | On Jun 4, 2009, jvhagerman Magalia, CA wrote: I have purchased from Hirt's Gardens on ebay prior to attempting to purchase again now. The plants I received before were mostly good and did well. However now he and his company won't even bother to reply to my before purchase questions. Evidently they don't need business as customer service is terrible. After reading all the comments especially the negative ones it's enough to make any one not purchase anything from this place. |
Negative | SKNBR (1 review) | On Jun 3, 2009, SKNBR wrote: This company stinks. My plants arrived, just about DOA. The roots were so matted, I can't imagine how long they've been sitting in the pots they arrived in. I also ordered seeds from them and I don't have high hopes of germination. It's $30 of my life I'll never get back again. Buyer beware. This company is horrible and should be ashamed of the products they sell. |
Neutral | fayesmom (1 review) | On Jun 3, 2009, fayesmom Haltom City, TX wrote: my god, well it looks like i have a 50-50 chance,huh....well it seems as though most of you have ordered plants or bulbs...i have ordered pumpkin seeds of different varieties what should i do if none of them ever grow? this is my first time ordering online..............im a little worried.bummer. |
Negative | perenniallyme (16 reviews) | On May 24, 2009, perenniallyme Jamaica Plain, MA (Zone 6a) wrote: Last fall I bought several packets of seed from Hirts through Amazon, because I had gift certificates there, and they had some unusual varieties. One packet they sent me was not what I ordered, but I didn't complain. However, most of the 8 or so not inexpensive packets contained no viable seed at all. Of course it took me through the winter and into the spring to determine that they were not viable, so I doubt I can do anything to get my wasted money back. |
Negative | lkinnj (1 review) | On May 20, 2009, lkinnj Hoboken, NJ wrote: Recently bought 4 tomato plants from this place. They came in a box. When I took the plants out of the box, they were all twisted and one had broken at the stem. The leaves have diseased spots all over. I worked with the merchant to get a refund. After sending pics, the merchant said they looked fine. Well they don't look fine comparing to tomato plants I have seen at local nurseries! Buyers beware. I will never order from this place again |
Neutral | fluffysquirrel (4 reviews) | On May 15, 2009, fluffysquirrel Sicklerville, NJ wrote: I've ordered a couple of times from this company, as I was attracted to the low price on Ebay. It took awhile to get here, but the plants were generous and healthy. Thing is, their customer service leaves alot to be desired. I called, and the woman who answered seemed moody and had no knowledge of the plant I had inquired about. "I dunno. *sigh* Hoooold on..." I was on hold for awhile, but she finally got back on the line and said they had one more of a particular plant. I saw they relisted it on Ebay for 17.99 rather than the original 7.99. Also, they don't answer their emails or Ebay correspondence. This can't be good for business. I won't be doing business with them anymore. |
Negative | eileentibet (4 reviews) | On May 14, 2009, eileentibet Center Barnstead, NH (Zone 5a) wrote: This winter I won item(s) on ebay that had been posted by Hirts. Yes, Hirts uses ebay to sell plants! I couldn't read or see my winnings on ebay from Hirts Garden even though I was the winner. |
Negative | Tex68 (7 reviews) | On May 12, 2009, Tex68 Long Branch, NJ (Zone 7a) wrote: I ordered 8 echinaceas and 4 globe thistles through eBay. I was aware they were STARTER PLANTS grown in 2x3" containers. Shipping was timely and the starter plants were shipped with tape all over to protect the dirt on the tiny pots. The plants looked healthy but obviously they were soo tiny as if they just sprouted from seeds. So tiny that 20 days later despite TLC, out of the 8 echinaceas, only 2 are growing new leaves, 3 are holding their breaths, and the other 3 looks like they're gonners. |
Positive | robertf562 (1 review) | On May 8, 2009, robertf562 Arlington Heights, IL wrote: This was my first time ordering by mail and I did not know what to expect. The price could not be beat. My order of 16 heirloom tomato plants arrived in 5 days. I was surprised that they were crammed into an 8" by 8" inch box. The dirt was taped down and the plants were surrounded by styrofoam peanuts. The plants were big and appeared to be healthy enough to survive the shipping. A little water and a day of sun was all they needed. |
« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | ... 10 Next »