Photo by Melody

Comments regarding Park Seed Company (aka Park's Gardens)

Click here to return to Park Seed Company (aka Park's Gardens)'s listing.

  Feedback History and Summary  
432 positives
111 neutrals
441 negatives

Comments:

« Previous Page 1 ... 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | ... 25 Next »

RatingAuthorContent
Positive Pitimpinai
(23 reviews)
On Mar 26, 2003, Pitimpinai Chicago, IL wrote:

Just received my plants. Oh, boy. oh boy. the Aster frikartii 'Moench' were HUGE!!, although I was surprised they came as bareroots. (Previously I got aster 'Moench' from Forestfarm in one gallon containers at HUGE shipment cost. They were much smaller than Park's & one had yellow blossoms!). This is the best Moench I have ever received.

I was also surprised to receive the plants this early. Normally, I received my shipment in April. Fortunately, the weather has been relatively warm. It is unpredictable in the Midwest. Last year we had frost on Mother's Day. Other times the temperature jumped swiftly to 70's in April.

I have been ordering from Park's for more than fifteen years and will continue ordering from them.


On August 22nd, 2003, nunoi added the following:

It is interesting to read other customers comments.

Now, I only order from Park's & Wayside somthing I cannot get from other sources. Park's & Wayside's are just too pricy, although I would order Clematis from them only, since the root system is the best and the price not too bad if ordered numerous plants at once. I just started to order roses from them. Very nice. I will try them again if I have room in my gardens.

And their replacements were always made without fuss. I like that because it is so disappointing to see a plant die or never leave out then receive no replacement for them.

I like their catalogs. Nice to look at, although we don't really need several copies of the same with different covers. We pay for them too of course but you get what we pay for.

I am not good at growing from seeds, so I only try the easy ones and get most of my seeds from Johny's Selected seeds instead.

On Jan 15, 2005, nunoi added the following:

I have ordered various plants & accessories from Park's & Wayside for over 15 years. Even though the quality of the plants seems to decline gradually, overall I will still order things from them.

On the surface, their plants may seem way overpriced, but their policy of replacement/refund with no hassle offsets the initial price.

I shied away from Park's & Wayside for a few years thinking I had found cheaper suppliers. Unfortunately those suppliers caused much more headache and hard feelings. Their plants turned out more expensive when they didn't grow true to name, didn't grow, etc. and were not replaced or refunded.
Positive Imhotep
(26 reviews)
On Mar 24, 2003, Imhotep Meridian, MS wrote:

Myself, mother, grandfather have delt with this company
over a total period of 60+ years, myself about 30+ years,
I am age 60.

This company, other than Burpee, is the "mother" of all
seed firms.

In these years count not 1 problem. this firm mostly has
varities no other firm has, except specialty houses. The
prices are reasonable, delivery is firm, quality is most
excellent and they stand by their products.

On a 1-10 scale, I give them 11+

Negative DaveA
(1 review)
On Mar 24, 2003, DaveA Watertown, WI (Zone 5a) wrote:

I liked most everything about park seed. Their website was well organized and reasonably informative. The shipping time was acceptable (about a week).

My sole complaint is that the first seed pack I opened was one of the bell peppers I ordered.

Like several of the other negative comments for Park Seed, I counted 12 seeds in a packet marked for 25. I have not opened the others yet to see if any others are short.

I have not contacted Park Seeds about this, I simply will not order from them again. It appears to be a long term quality control issue with them judging from the other complaints here.

Positive kidhorn
(13 reviews)
On Mar 19, 2003, kidhorn Redland, MD wrote:

I ordered some seeds and some growing trays. The order arrived on time, in good shape, and everything was corrct.

Positive Sosa
(11 reviews)
On Mar 19, 2003, Sosa wrote:

My seed order was received in less then one week at this very busy time for seed companies. All of my order was filled.
I know some hve been concerned with Park's germination rates. Last year I had good success with the vegatable seeds and annuals. My perennial seeds did not fare well, but It was most likely my own inexperience. I will see what happens this year. I also get seeds from Johnny's and Territorial and locally, so all my eggs are not in one basket.
Park's does provide nice one stop shopping for a wide variety. My Park's Wopper cantelopes last year were huge! In 2001 I ordered fall planted bulbs and all grew well. I switched to Brent & Becks, Zimmerman's, and Old House Gardens for bulbs for 2002 becauce of selection. I will continue to do a selective business with Park!.

Negative Kelli
(13 reviews)
On Mar 17, 2003, Kelli L.A. (Canoga Park), CA (Zone 10a) wrote:

The germination rate of the seeds was not very good.

Negative FMW
(2 reviews)
On Mar 16, 2003, FMW Charlotte, NC wrote:

This *USED* to be a 5 star company, but has declined rapidly over the last 3 years. In fall, I placed orders totalling over $200. Well, the daffs were rotted, most of the plumbago was dead/moldy/empty pots, the trycirtis aren't contemplating coming up, the Arkansas star were dead, and the Niobe clematis was LESS than a root. Their replacement plants were no better. I wasted my afternoon searching for *A* root in the pots.

I normally order A LOT (I love my gardens) but I'd get (and did get)better response from WALMART plants.

Positive sparker
(4 reviews)
On Mar 13, 2003, sparker Queensbury, NY wrote:

Fast service. Five days. Good germination. 90%+. What else do you need. Sun Please!

Positive robacameron
(19 reviews)
On Mar 10, 2003, robacameron wrote:

I have always had good luck with Park's. I ordered their 4-leaf-clover seeds one year and they really did grow true 4 leaf clovers! Their seeds stay preserved and fresh in their foil packets, which makes them germinate well. They carry many popular kinds of seeds, as well as their own great ones developed by themselves. From what I hear their seed starting supplies are really good too. I haven't ordered plants from them yet, though. Their seed is one of the first to arrive in the mailbox out of the many other companies I order from at the same time. I will definetely keep Park's on my good list.

Positive OHbluebird
(1 review)
On Mar 7, 2003, OHbluebird wrote:

I was very happy with Park Seed. My seed order came quickly and I received the quantity stated in the catalog. I started my tomato seeds and 100% of them germinated. They are now happy healthy seedlings. I've bought Park's Whopper tomato plants in years past (always having to travel far and wide to find them) and I was so happy to get my hands on their catalog and order some of those seeds! The best tomatoes I've ever grown.

Positive tmagent
(3 reviews)
On Feb 28, 2003, tmagent San Diego, CA wrote:

I've always had very good luck with Parks. I've been ordering from them for years. I also think they have the best catalog on the market. BUT....I have experienced some seeds that do not germinate and I've always blamed it on myself until reading the negative comments on here. I must say though, I always order my seeds and supplies on their website and I usually get my order within the week. I only had a problem once with a container of fertilizer that leaked and they replaced it instantly.

I find that some of their see packets are more expensive than other companies, but it all seems to average out. I love the foil packets. I always start my seeds with their Park Starts and have had great luck. I especially like the fact that they have replacement cylinders for these.

Since I live in Southern California, I'm able to find plants fairly cheap and of good quality at Lowes and Home Depot, so I've not ordered any plants from them.

All in all, I give Parks a two thumbs up based on my dealing with them.


On August 12th, 2003, tmagent added the following:

8-12-03

I received an email from Park's last week with a fantastic sale of up to 75% off seeds and supplies. I took them up on it and saved a bundle. I received all of my items, none were out of stock, within one week. I'm impressed! I love their selection of hard to find seeds and their service is excellent.
Positive SCBoy
(2 reviews)
On Feb 27, 2003, SCBoy wrote:

I am a beginning gardener and I have found Park Seed to be willing to go the extra mile to help me. I have had numerous contact with their representatives and they have always been professional. I did have some problems with germination rates until I asked about them and realized I wasn't planting them in the best of spots. I would buy from them again -- and I already have!

I love the bulb catalog and I've been very pleased with the Daylilies and Tulips that I have purchased from Park Bulbs. I plan to buy more from them in the future.

Positive hangsix
(8 reviews)
On Feb 24, 2003, hangsix wrote:

Park seeds is outstanding ! Love there foil gold packets
excellent turn-around time on shipping , good prices for
seeds . Also good growth rate on what I've planted can say
nothing negative good company .

Positive vieja
(8 reviews)
On Feb 23, 2003, vieja albuquerque, NM (Zone 7a) wrote:

I ordered seed and a grow light/mini-greenhouse/sponge pellets and heat mat from Park's; the service was prompt and the order arrived in great condition. Had 100% germination of the seeds in the sponges!

Though I haven't ordered plants or other nursery stock from Park's, I am very pleased with my seed order and grow set- up from them. I was almost ready to give up on ordering by mail as I have had terrible luck with others (Gurney's and Burgess) the last couple of years!

Positive karenhane
(15 reviews)
On Feb 23, 2003, karenhane Manchester, CT (Zone 5a) wrote:

I ordered seeds from Park, but not before checking this website. The selection was great, and I recieved my seeds extremely fast. I also ordered from two other places on the same day and have yet to recieve my shipping confirmation! thanks, Park Seed!


On February 22nd, 2005, karenhane added the following:

we are now starting our vegetable seeds using "root-trainer" starting trays purchased through parks. we are having great success with these trays as they hold alot of starter mix , they are easy to water, and they make transplanting tender seedlings very easy to do. we highly recommend them to anyone who is into vegetable gardening or growing from seeds.
Negative WVGrower
(6 reviews)
On Feb 21, 2003, WVGrower wrote:

After over 30 positive years, I was very disappointed with germination rates of seeds I purchased last year. Many varieties failed completely. A packet that was supposed to contain 25 seeds only contained 2 or 3 (this was replaced but only 2 germinated!). I ordered a dahlia at a cost of about $10 in 2001 and was disgusted when I received a single piece of tuber with no buds!

Negative elfeik
(32 reviews)
On Feb 19, 2003, elfeik Near Kansas City, MO (Zone 6a) wrote:

Actually I would give Park a 7 on a 1-10 scale. A broad selection of plants, seeds, & supplies. Their plants are good quality, but high priced and the seeds have preformed fairly well over the years.


On August 21st, 2007, elfeik changed the rating from positive to negative and added the following:

Lately I would give them a 2 out of 10 - I read they were bought by new owners who either don't know or care about how the company is run
Positive tantaw123
(2 reviews)
On Feb 11, 2003, tantaw123 Lubbock, TX wrote:

I have ordered from Parks Seed many times and they have always sent the order ontime and the order has always been filled corectly. Two years ago I received some plants that were damaged and they replaced them immediatly.

Positive growing
(3 reviews)
On Feb 7, 2003, growing Osceola, WI wrote:

I like Park Seed for a couple of reasons. They stand behind their products. I did not have any trouble getting the couple of seeds that didn't grow replaced. If you have any trouble at all you can contact them and they will help you with it. I once had some seeds that did not germinate and when I spoke with them I found it was not warm enough where I had them. They were still willing to replace them. However I did not feel it was their place to do so after all it was I that did wrong. In the center of their catalog they have a "Index and Germination/Culture Guide" which in it's self is very helpful. I will continue to order from them as I have for many years.

Positive rulien
(12 reviews)
On Feb 3, 2003, rulien Hagerman, ID (Zone 6a) wrote:

I have ordered seeds and plants from Park Seed, for many years, and unless things change I will continue to do so.

They publish a wonderful catalog, exhibiting many plant varieties and wonderful plant propogation information.

Order problems (which are view) have always been handled courteously, professionally, and to my complete satisfation.

I would definitely recommend Park Seed to my gardening friends.

Negative Kelly_FL
(2 reviews)
On Feb 2, 2003, Kelly_FL wrote:

This is my first time ordering from them. I ordered 6 packs of seed, opened the first which were candy lillies and package said 25 seeds. In the package were 20 seeds and some so sad looking that I doubt they will be viable. I am ticked off. I won't bother writing to them about it, I just won't order from them again. Wonder what the other 5 packs have in them...

Positive ocimum_nate
(8 reviews)
On Jan 30, 2003, ocimum_nate American Fork, UT (Zone 5a) wrote:

I bought Holy Basil from Parks. What came up is not Holy Basil. I have emailed them pictures and documentation to back up my claims but I have not gotten any response back from their herb specialist. This has been going on since Spring of 2002. It is now almost February of 2003. I just want them to admit their mistake and make restitution.


On February 14th, 2003, ocimum_nate added the following:

Parks decided to send me more seed and told me that if I had any more problems to take it up with their supplier. I am currently in the process of doing that. I am a bit jaded however because they told me that they had looked into things and that I had been informed of their findings, which NEVER happened. They never sited sources for their findings or anything. I will never purchase from Park seeds again!
On February 19th, 2003, ocimum_nate changed the rating from negative to positive and added the following:

Parks sent me new seeds. I opened the packages and was pleased to find true holy basil seeds.

While communicating with Parks seed supplier I found that they didn't supply Parks with the Holy basil seeds for the year that I purchased them. What this means is that they are now offering true holy basil and that Parks has made restitution for the problem that I encountered. I now retract my previous statements and would like to offer my appreciation for their service.
Neutral Eric_OH
(55 reviews)
On Jan 21, 2003, Eric_OH Columbus, OH (Zone 6a) wrote:

Long experience with ordering seeds - orders are always shipped promptly and accurately. Germination is generally good to excellent. Value is mid-range (better than T&M, not as good as Pinetree).


On March 5th, 2006, Eric_OH changed the rating from positive to neutral and added the following:

I was disappointed to see the company statement recently added to this site. Instead of taking the opportunity to reassure customers and pledge improvements, it seems aimed more at criticizing them for having the nerve to say anything negative here about Park's.

I continue to find Park's a good source for certain kinds of seed. Based on the reports from other gardeners and the company message in response, I will avoid buying plants from them and affiliated companies.
Positive cmdrzog
(2 reviews)
On Jan 20, 2003, cmdrzog wrote:

Over 40 years dealing with them . A mixup in variety of rose sent was solved in less than 2 minutes with a phone call. Would not hesitate to reccomend.

Positive tyshee
(9 reviews)
On Jan 19, 2003, tyshee Kenai, AK wrote:

I rate Park's as the top seed website on the net. I order large quantities of seeds and I order by the internet. They always ship immediately. They respond to all emails rapidly and most of the seeds germinate well. If there is a problem with plants it is usually my fault. I order three hundred dollars or more of seeds and I try many new annuals. Some just don't do well in my Alaskan climate. The seeds germinate and do well in the greenhouse but when we have variable weather conditions it is not Parks fault. I have people come over to walk through my yard and view the flowers. I have had a commercial greenhouse manager ask me to help him with his seed ordering. My beautiful yard and flower reputation is partly do to Parks seeds. I have only had one plant I ordered not survive and I am sure Parks would have replaced it had I notified them. It was a bare root plant. Poor germination of seeds is generally because I did something wrong such as over-water the wrong plants or I ordered something very difficult to germinate (Park's always tells you this and sends you extra seeds to compensate for it).


On January 31st, 2003, tyshee added the following:
I emailed Parks today because my New Guinnea Impatients only had one seed germinate and I followed all the directions carefully. Within one hour they responded stating a new package of seeds would be in the mail immediately and that they were warranteed for one year. In my opinion that was extremely good service. They also wrote when I placed my order and stated several poppy species of the perennial type were not rated for my zone. I wrote and related we usually grow them as annuals and some people have them winter over. They asked me to let them know if my last years wintered over. This tells me they are very interested in their customers if we treat them with respect we will get great service. This is only one of several problems I have rapidly worked out with them. Yes the seeds can be expensive but you get what you pay for.
Positive daviddmc
(3 reviews)
On Jan 17, 2003, daviddmc wrote:

I had excellent results with all the seeds I ordered from Parks. I think they're great for seeds. I did, however receive some very scrawny clematis plants, which one of died quickly. I never asked for a replacement, but imagine they would have sent me one. The seed germination was great, and the bio-dome seed starter works great also.

Positive Debralee
(2 reviews)
On Jan 7, 2003, Debralee wrote:

I have bought plants and seeds from Parks for many years. I have enjoyed visiting their gardens in bloom. I have always been happy with the product and the service.

Neutral tomatogin
(2 reviews)
On Jan 7, 2003, tomatogin wrote:

I have ordered from Park Seed for the past two years. I got acceptable germination rates from their melon seeds, But after reading other comments I think that the erratic germination of my corn seeds may not have been my fault. As you know, even germination is very important for cross pollination. I will buy my corn seeds elsewhere.

Negative mingsmimi
(2 reviews)
On Jan 7, 2003, mingsmimi Sharpsville, PA (Zone 5a) wrote:

first time using them.For SHAME! Ordered the Fuji mixed morning glory grouping of 5 seed packets. SO DISAPPOINTED> I was lucky to get 4 or the fuji. Got a handfull of the others. Maybe,a handfull. Pictures are NOT true of what you get thats for sure. Would never bother with them again. Only half the seeds in each packet sprouted.
Called them. they said they would replace. Still waiting. But. its only been 9 months...........

Positive gardenpro
(2 reviews)
On Dec 29, 2002, gardenpro wrote:

I have done business with Park Seeds for twenty-four years, and my grandparents before me were dedicated customers. I have never been dissatisfied.

Positive cardeda
(1 review)
On Dec 28, 2002, cardeda Lapeer, MI (Zone 5a) wrote:

Year 2001 I ordered bare root clematis. I planted them upside down and, of course, they died. I admited my error to Park and they sent me a voucher so I could try again next year with new plants.

I appreciate a company that saw me as a customer worth keeping, even in my ignorance.

Negative chieumai
(2 reviews)
On Dec 19, 2002, chieumai Richardson, TX wrote:

I've ordered seeds and plants from this company. Germination rates on seeds were very poor. Only the marigolds came up. Live tomato plants were good, but the potentilla was dead. I called for a replacement of the potentilla, and they sent me another dead plant. I didn't bother trying to contact them again. Their catalog and website are very nice to look at, but their quality is not good.

Positive elenapro
(1 review)
On Nov 13, 2002, elenapro wrote:

I shop for seeds, supplies, etc. VEEERY extensively (exclusively through the Internet, though)looking for best variety, shipping terms and instructions. Out of my experience, the choice of seeds offered by Park Seed and their super low delivery prices are cumulatively unmatched. Seed packaging is superb. Regarding germination rates, I bought a 25-seed pack of coleus and had 28 seeds germinated on a window sill in 4 days with no fussing on my part, not even additional lighting or plastic cover!

Positive mudpuppie
(3 reviews)
On Oct 14, 2002, mudpuppie Charleston, SC (Zone 8b) wrote:

I have received two rose bushes in the past 4 months and they were healthy on arrival. In June I received a bare-root Dainty Bess (Hybrid Tea Rose) which flourished and has bloomed the rest of the summer. I just received a Mutabilis (China Rose) in a gallon container and it is a healthy plant full of new growth and buds.

Negative sarahjones
(1 review)
On Sep 17, 2002, sarahjones wrote:

Long in the business, a beautiful catalog, great customer service, sometimes a poor product.
Have ordered seeds and plants. Most years the seeds were great. Last year the seeds barely germinated. (vinca) Good thing I wasn't counting on them.
Also ordered a daylily collection. Many of the plants were so moldy they fell apart. They replaced them immediatly, however, the replacement also contained moldy, dead plants!
Have also ordered clematis vines from them. One year nothing grew. I did better with Wal-mart boxed and potted clematis at 1/3rd the price. This year they grew, but they send you very small plants.
I would sadly say try to look elsewhere for your dream plant before ordering from them, as they send out small, weak plants. Seeds are another issue. Since they carry a great assortment, and seeds are cheap, you won't lose too much if they don't germinate.

Negative debidolphin
(3 reviews)
On Sep 14, 2002, debidolphin Tryon, NC (Zone 7a) wrote:

I ordered several pks of seeds this spring and planted them all. I had a very low rate of germination. Some packs grew nothing at all. I also ordered from another co. and almost everything grew. I won't waste my money again.

Positive twoholes
(6 reviews)
On Aug 22, 2002, twoholes wrote:

Very good overall. A bit pricey. Consistent.

Negative Mackienorth
(1 review)
On Aug 20, 2002, Mackienorth wrote:

I have been ordering from Park Seed for years, however the germination rate for some seeds has been less than acceptable the last two years. Also, the seeds I ordered were not what I received for two items.

Negative Lakesidelandscaper
(2 reviews)
On Jul 18, 2002, Lakesidelandscaper wrote:

I have ordered many seed varieties from Park, I also have had very poor germination success. When you depend on this for a living, it can be more than frustrating. The seeds are packaged well (foil VS paper), many even double sealed! I expected more and didn't get it. I have since found other sources for my seed orders.

« Previous Page 1 ... 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | ... 25 Next »