Comments regarding Henry Field's Seed & Nursery
Click here to return to Henry Field's Seed & Nursery's listing.
|
Comments:
« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... 7 Next »
Rating | Author | Content |
Negative | wweller (1 review) | On May 26, 2009, wweller McCordsville, IN wrote: I have now had to contact customer service twice to find out were my order is. They have changed the charge to my bank account 6 time for one order, that was broken up into 3 shipments. The man I spoke to today should not be a customer service rep & when I pointed out that the way he was speaking to me was not appropiate, he became extremely rude. |
Negative | aprilavery (1 review) | On May 3, 2009, aprilavery Franklin, TN wrote: I placed an order on 3/20/09 that consisted of seeds and plants. I expected the seeds to ship immediately and the plants to ship in late April (I'm in zone 6). |
Positive | lilaclily (36 reviews) | On Apr 25, 2009, lilaclily Lombard, IL (Zone 5a) wrote: I started out very apprehensive about ordering from them, based on all the negative reviews here. But I really wanted a Carmine Jewel bush cherry and they had a 50% off coupon as well. I crossed my fingers and took a chance. This was back in February. |
Negative | tedmartin (2 reviews) | On Apr 22, 2009, tedmartin Iselin, NJ wrote: After reading the other posts and a little rersearch, I have decided not to buy from this company; mainly because it is part of a major marketer using this name and many others like Gurney, Michigan Bulb, Spring Hill, etc. All are part of the "Scarlet Tanager" company and will offer the same product at different prices with different sales gimicks. Con job! You are actually dealing with one company trying to act as several companies and this tends to lead to a lack of quality and service although they do make an effort to resolve problems. I am looking for quality product and service and this company shows almost a 50% negative rating from it's customers. Not for me. |
Negative | ralph5656 (1 review) | On Mar 24, 2009, ralph5656 Beckley, WV wrote: never sent confirmation of order as promised. within 24 hours has turned into 10 days. delivery date was today mar 24 and order was never processed nor shipped. sent emails didn't get a single response. Never had problems in the past until this year. This is where we part ways. On March 24th, 2009, ralph5656 added the following: just noticed since I didn't get anything on the first delivery date they have set a NEW delivery date. If they send me any thing, I'm sending it back pronto! |
Positive | MyZone8 (6 reviews) | On Mar 13, 2009, MyZone8 Collins, United States wrote: Ordered 2 dwarf citrus trees and 2 bare root fruit trees everything arrived promptly and in good condition. Plus extra!! Staff was very pleasant and helpful over phone. Will order again. |
Positive | michelle0031 (1 review) | On Mar 5, 2009, michelle0031 Owendale, MI wrote: I ordered almost all of my seeds this year from Henry Fields. |
Positive | susandonb1141 (3 reviews) | On Jan 7, 2009, susandonb1141 Triad(for a few more months), NC (Zone 7a) wrote: Last year I ordered seeds and 3 year old asparagus crowns from Henry Field's, even though I lost 5 of my gus crowns the rest did great and produced gus a few months after I planted them. I was not able to call the company about the 5 crowns that did not come up due to spinal surgery and being laid up for 8 months. This year I just ordered seeds from HF and received them quickly. I plan on ordering 200 sweet potato slips in the next few weeks from HF and have always been happy with their products. I have already sown spinach, brocc and lettuces from the seeds I just ordered a couple weeks ago, and they all germinated with in 5 days, wonderful! |
Negative | rovingray (1 review) | On Jun 22, 2008, rovingray Ewing, VA wrote: I placed an large (at least for me) on-line vegetable seed order earlier this year with Henry Field’s. On Jun 22, 2008, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery responded with: " On Jul 31, 2008 3:36 PM, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery added: D-mailed Customer on June 25 asking for information so I could locate their account and try to come up with a possible resolution to satisfy the Customer. As of July 31, no response has been received." |
Neutral | MorsisX (27 reviews) | On Jun 10, 2008, MorsisX Lockport, IL (Zone 5b) wrote: Ordered an albeit cheap tree peony, they sent me in late winter (for Chicago planting!) a twig thing that did not sprout. Had to break the frost to plant... |
Positive | gardengalrn (1 review) | On Jun 1, 2008, gardengalrn Belleville, KS wrote: I made a large order early in spring. I had ordered one of their specials on raspberry plants, buy 1 (set of 3), get one free. Both sets looked decent but only 1 set of 3 plants leafed out. I emailed and got prompt service and was shipped 3 more plants to replace them. The replacements were of even better quality (larger, too) than the original. All bulbs and rootstock were great, too. I would order again. |
Positive | kevin_mic (1 review) | On May 7, 2008, kevin_mic Pleasant Grove, UT wrote: Near the end of April 2008 I decided to order from Henry Fields. I ordered 2 Female Arctic Beauty Kiwi plants and 1 Male Arctic Beauty Kiwi plant. It is now May 6th and I received my plants today. They came quickly and were healthy. I would buy from Henry Fields again. |
Negative | ceresone (12 reviews) | On Apr 17, 2008, ceresone Willow Springs, MO (Zone 6b) wrote: I ordered 18 Raspberry Plants from this company. About 2 weeks before shipping date, the notified me they were out of one lot. I promptly called, and told them they could send XXX instead, in order to complete my order. OH, NO, that would be a substution, and that wasnt allowed. I tried to explain that I was merely giving them a chance to fill my order, and this was refused. On April 18th, 2008, ceresone added the following: To be perfectly fair, I have found they dis-allowed my 25.00 coupon, but they did cancel my amount due. As it stands, I still feel they owe ME money, and they felt I owed them. Rest of comments and ratings stand as stated. On Apr 17, 2008, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery responded with: " On May 27, 2008 8:09 AM, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery added: Contacted Customer on 4/22/08 for possible resolution; no response." |
Positive | proxidice (3 reviews) | On Apr 14, 2008, proxidice Parkersburg, WV wrote: I have ordered five Walker's Low catmints. The plants have arrived quickly. They were dormant roots in a bag. I planted them two days later and in a few days they were all showing green growth. The price was definately a bargain, and yet, they're growing nicely. I will order from this company again in the future. |
Negative | marihoughton (1 review) | On Apr 12, 2008, marihoughton Portland, OR wrote: 127993 shipment number On Apr 12, 2008, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery responded with: " On May 27, 2008 8:10 AM, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery added: Contacted the Customer on 4/22/08 for possible resolution; have received no response as of 5/27/08." |
Negative | fleabags (3 reviews) | On Apr 10, 2008, fleabags Independence, KY wrote: Mountain Laurel died on me and asked for replacement and they said they didn't have anymore, come to find out on their website that they did. They were nice enough to issue a credit but that will not cover the $7 shipping charges...Maybe put my credits together and try to use them. Guess you get what you pay for. This will be last time using Henry Field & Michigan Bulb |
Positive | gardenenvy (6 reviews) | On Apr 4, 2008, gardenenvy Dover, NC wrote: I placed an order with Henry Fields for the first time this year. My parents got a glimpse of the catalog, and picked out some seeds and tomato food they wanted to try in the garden, and since i had a $25 coupon, I ordered enough to get the discount. |
Negative | juliep127 (6 reviews) | On Mar 23, 2008, juliep127 Louisville, KY wrote: I purchased Calidiums from this company. When they came they were mushy. I called and they sent me more. BUT they were still mushy. I will never buy from them again!!! On Mar 23, 2008, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery responded with: " On Mar 24, 2008 10:29 AM, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery added: Unfortunately, when dealing with "live" products, such as bulbs or plants, they do go bad during the shipping process; we don't ship out bad products. And, according to our satisfaction guarantee, and the Customer's statement, her caladiums were replaced." |
Positive | engravogirl (3 reviews) | On Mar 15, 2008, engravogirl Godley, TX wrote: In mid January I ordered a variety of seeds, some Asparagus roots, and Cannas. As an afterthought I decided to risk ordering one live Brugmansia plant. |
Negative | trc65 (8 reviews) | On Mar 14, 2008, trc65 Galesburg, IL wrote: On February 13 I ordered 11 packets of common vegetable and flowers seeds. I kept waiting for the package to ship and it was finally shipped two weeks later on February 26. Seven days later I finally received the seed. The day after receiving the seed I started opening packets to start the seed. The first packet I opened contained only 7 instead of 35 seeds. No problem, mistakes happen. The second pack of seeds contained only 10 instead of 30 seeds - am I starting to see a pattern? The third packet was only 10% short of seeds, so I'm getting better the more I open. The rest of the order all contained the proper amount (or more) of seed. I emailed the company and received an automated email stating that someone would personally reply to me within 48 hours. Six days later I finally got an email saying that replacement seed would be shipped to me. It then took them 2 days after that to ship the seeds. If previous timeline is indicative, I should have the seeds in only seven more days!! In summary I should have all the seed I ordered only six weeks after placing the order. Loooong time to process order, looong shipping time, poor customer service. You just lost another customer. On Mar 14, 2008, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery responded with: " On May 27, 2008 8:11 AM, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery added: I contacted the Customer on 4/22/08 for possible resolution; as of 5/27/08, have received no response." |
Positive | Johnboy07 (3 reviews) | On Feb 17, 2008, Johnboy07 Covington, LA wrote: I recently ordered fruit trees from Henry Field. The communication was good, and the trees arrived timely. I will definitely order from them again. I was very happy with the quality and condition of the stock. |
Neutral | Ladykitsu (4 reviews) | On Jan 26, 2008, Ladykitsu Westminster, CO wrote: I ordered several live plants in the 2007 planting year. The buy one get one free on several of the items, on top of the $25 discount was too much to resist. If I remember correctly I paid about $26 for 100 strawberry plants, 4 hosta and 1 blackberry (3 plants) On Jan 26, 2008, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery responded with: " On May 27, 2008 8:13 AM, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery added: Contacted the Customer on 4/22/08 for possible resolution; as of 5/27/08, have received no response." |
Negative | boxcar_grower (5 reviews) | On Jan 4, 2008, boxcar_grower South Hadley, MA (Zone 6a) wrote: Last year in mid-winter I ordered 24 raspberry plants. I was assured they would arrive for correct planting time for my area. I live in Zone 5 Massachusetts. They stated that they ship to my area starting April 15th. Perfect I say. Well March 12th the raspberries arrived. There was 2 feet of snow on the ground and 1 foot of frost in the ground. I called Henry Fields and they told me it was the proper time for my area. They must be smoking something. 90% of the time we have snow into April. On Jan 4, 2008, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery responded with: " On May 27, 2008 8:14 AM, Henry Field's Seed & Nursery added: Contacted the Customer on 4/22/08 for possible resolution; as of 5/27/08 have received no response." |
Neutral | rasely (2 reviews) | On Dec 28, 2007, rasely McDonough, NY wrote: I ordered potatoes, onions, and strawberry plants last year (spring 2007) from Fields. They arrived here in upstate NY mid April when there was a foot of snow on the ground! Is it too much to ask that a company this big could check zones before shipping? On January 15th, 2008, rasely changed the rating from negative to neutral and added the following: I am changing the rating to neutral because shortly after posting this review, I received an apologetic email from a customer rep. The email, however, appeared to be a form-letter type response and didn't really address the problem of shipping time. As I emailed back, the plants were ok (not great but they did grow) so I wasn't asking for a refund, just that they pay more attention to shipping dates. I did order from Fields again this year (who could resist their $25 off coupon?) but for supplies, not live plants. |
Negative | celloise (3 reviews) | On Nov 7, 2007, celloise Birmingham, AL wrote: I've been dealing with Henry Field's for about two years now. I've noticed that they don't tend to be in a hurry to ship their plants, and their customer service isn't so hot. On March 5th, 2008, celloise changed the rating from neutral to negative and added the following: OK, as an update, I planted the bulbs mentioned in the above comment in the fall. I noticed about a month ago that some of them were sending up shoots, which surprised me since both the tulips and the alliums I ordered weren't supposed to bloom until spring. I just figured I must have planted too shallow. NOPE. Two days ago, I realized that the "tulips" I planted were actually crocus! They sent me the wrong bulbs. I then called customer service and the representative asked me why I couldn't tell that the bulbs were crocus instead of tulips when I planted them. "Are you kidding?" I asked. I have no idea. This is my first real flower garden, so I haven't a clue what the difference would be. The only bulb I can recognize is lilies, since they are so distinctive. Needless to say, they are offering me a credit on the bulbs. However, I hate to pay shipping (again) on bulbs that they messed up on the first time, no matter what sort of credit they are offering. So, I'm downgrading my rating after that little incident and will never order from Henry Field's again. On March 5th, 2008, celloise added the following: OK, as an update, I planted the bulbs mentioned in the above comment in the fall. I noticed about a month ago that some of them were sending up shoots, which surprised me since both the tulips and the alliums I ordered weren't supposed to bloom until spring. I just figured I must have planted too shallow. NOPE. Two days ago, I realized that the "tulips" I planted were actually crocus! They sent me the wrong bulbs. I then called customer service and the representative asked me why I couldn't tell that the bulbs were crocus instead of tulips when I planted them. "Are you kidding?" I asked. I have no idea. This is my first real flower garden, so I haven't a clue what the difference would be. The only bulb I can recognize is lilies, since they are so distinctive. It was great the CS Rep tried to make it out like it was my fault, rather than theirs. Needless to say, they are offering me a credit on the bulbs. However, I hate to pay shipping (again) on bulbs that they messed up on the first time, no matter what sort of credit they are offering. So, I'm downgrading my rating after that little incident and will never order from Henry Field's again. |
Neutral | GardeningGuru (2 reviews) | On Oct 30, 2007, GardeningGuru Lilburn, GA wrote: My experience with this company has been mixed. I first tried them right before they went bankrupt, and I never received the order I placed with them. I tried them one more time a couple years later after they were took over by Gardern's Alive and ordered a few trees from them, but they all soon died. Their customer service remains weak, but their shipping prices are very good. Be cautious when ordering live plants from them. |
Positive | momtoanangel74 (2 reviews) | On Oct 24, 2007, momtoanangel74 Davisburg, MI wrote: I placed my first order knowing they had a so called bad reputation, but I figured I would make a small order in case it was a bad experience I wouldn't be out a lot of money. |
Positive | CedarBerry (8 reviews) | On Oct 15, 2007, CedarBerry Oakland, OR wrote: With my first order from Henry Field's, I bought quite a few bareroot plants on sale. They arrived completely dry and mostly brown, and a number of the plants never grew at all, while some grew poorly. I contacted customer service, which replied promptly and courteously that replacement plants would be sent. |
Positive | greenbrain (10 reviews) | On Sep 3, 2007, greenbrain Madison, IL (Zone 6b) wrote: I ordered & received blackberry & raspberry plants from HF last Spring. The success rate of these bareroot plants were much much better than the potted plants I purchased from a more reputable mail order company. These plants produced fruit the first summer. I've been ordering from HF for 25 years now -- mostly vegie seeds or small fruit. I'll most likely continue to order from this company as long as they have the varieties that I'm looking for & at reasonable prices. I've never had any problems that weren't resolved to my satisfaction. |
Negative | sweetpeaDC (1 review) | On Jul 16, 2007, sweetpeaDC Arlington, VA wrote: This is NOT a reputable firm. I was offered "$10 off $30 order" as a first-time customer, but the $10 was not applied. I was offered "one plant with each plant bought", but the extra plants were not included. When no one responded to my queries, I checked a customer page and found a note, in teeny tiny type, saying plants would be shipped in OCTOBER, long after the growing season is finished. Now I am sorry I ever gave these guys my card numbers, as I'll have to check my credit statements forever. Caveat emptor. |
Positive | hannahss (4 reviews) | On Jul 9, 2007, hannahss Freeman, MO (Zone 6a) wrote: I ordered from Gurney/Henry Field this spring after ordering in the past. All plants arrived alive, and all but 2 survived our very difficult spring. I planted hostas, raspberries, chokecherries, bush cherries, and burning bush. One plant remained dormant for 2 months!! but I knew it was alive because it was green under the bark. In all fairness, I got what I paid for, everything grew, and the company can hardly be responsible for extended hard freeze and days of heavy rain following. |
Neutral | brandie21 (11 reviews) | On Jun 14, 2007, brandie21 Tucson, AZ (Zone 8a) wrote: I placed an order thru the mail with Henry Fields in January 2007 for a packet of Red Hamburger Onions Seeds, Petunia Seeds, and 150 peat pots, the total was only about 20 dollars. I had ordered from them before but I had moved since then so I corrected the ship to address on the order form and the sent it with a check. On April 17th, 2008, brandie21 changed the rating from negative to neutral and added the following: I had said in my earlier review that I would never order from them again but I did and I was pleasantly surprised that the service was better than ever. I orders 5 or 6 packages of seeds, 6 Raspberry Plants, 6 Blackberry Plants, and 2 blueberry plants. I received 5 of the seed packets within 2 weeks of placing my order. Then about 1 week after that my raspberries and blueberries arrived, then about 1 week later my blackberries. About a week after that I received a refund check for the one pack of seeds that they were out of them. This doesn't make up for the way they treated me before but I can at least give them some credit for treating me better. We'll have to wait and see what happens if I order from them again. |
Negative | jt0791 (2 reviews) | On Jun 6, 2007, jt0791 Pembroke, MA wrote: bought 3 mountain laurel and one columbine... the packaging was fine but the 3 mountain laurel were in horrible shape dried out roots cement like..... leaves are very brittle...will not order ever again |
Negative | Wandasue (1 review) | On Jun 5, 2007, Wandasue South Webster, OH wrote: 4/02/2004--I ordered 180.00 us dollars) to henry fields company, when I finally received the ordered it came in 2 different deliveries, Everything was dead, the plants had no dirt on them, they look dorment, so I thought thats how they shipped, come to find out its 2 years later after planting and nothing I have nothing its all dead, I ordered several garden seeds and plants, strawberry plants were suppose to be free for ordering over 50 dollars worth of merchandise, well I never received them. |
Negative | greeneyes45 (1 review) | On May 31, 2007, greeneyes45 Pleasant Prairie, WI wrote: Placed order 08-23-2006 with a promised ship date of Strawberry Plants in March 2007. Then the date was changed to April and then May and now June 2007. No plants and no communication from company. Will never shop here again. |
Negative | fun2garden (5 reviews) | On May 12, 2007, fun2garden Jefferson City, MO wrote: HORRIBLE MATH SKILLS! I ordered 2 sets of the football mum collection and 1 set of cushion mum collection last spring. That was a total of 18 plants. The plants did not bloom at all last year. This spring, none of the plants returned. I contacted the company. A representative stated that a replacement would be shipped. Upon arrival, I was eager to open the box and plant the mums. However, was shocked to see that only 1 cushion mum was sent. Note to Henry Fields: 1 is not equal to 18!!!!! |
Positive | Norwell (3 reviews) | On May 5, 2007, Norwell Round Lake, IL (Zone 5a) wrote: I have ordered from Henry Field's for the past two years with no trouble whatsoever. Last year (2006) I ordered some seeds and bareroot material (hostas and astilbes) which did fine and are coming back with a vigorous vengence this year. This year I ordered some more bare root material and seeds. Germination on the seeds has been excellent as I will have far too many seedlings to deal with and, the bare root peonies are doing just fine. I used a coupon both years with no incident, and will order from them in the future. |
Positive | upnorthlady (2 reviews) | On May 4, 2007, upnorthlady Waubun, MN wrote: After reading all these negative comments, I was scared to order from this company, but I had pretty good luck with them in the past, and the prices were good, so I sent in an order and used the $25 off coupon. My order arrived in two packages, the seeds came almost immediately at the price stated, and the blueberries and grapes arrived in plenty of time for spring planting. They were very well packed, and healthy. The grapes are already growing nicely, the blueberries looked good, but so far are just growing small buds. The $25 off coupon was subtracted properly. My experience with this company was just as positive as in the past. I sent my order in by regular mail, not online, so I didn't have any of the online problems I see that others have had. I will definitely order from them again. |
Negative | anna11 (1 review) | On Apr 14, 2007, anna11 Singapore, Singapore wrote: I am from Singapore and I ordered seeds and bulbs amounting to about US$220 from Henry Fields for shipping to a friend in Ukiah, California. When I ordered, the customer service was very helpful and I was very thankful and posted a hard copy of the order, shipping address and check and even a thank you card to them. A few weeks later, my friend in America received a letter from Henry Fields informing us that the prices on the plants had gone up and they would not deliver a single plant to us. I went back to the website, reordered using the new and more expensive prices to make up the same amount of $220 and emailed the order to them. I also posted a hard copy of the letter to them. In addition, I also requested my friend from Ukiah to post a copy of the new order and the letter we received from Henry Fields to them. |