What is the difference?

Kerrville, TX

In Potting Soil and Potting Mix?

Forestville, CA(Zone 9a)

Technically Potting mix or planter mix does not contain any soil. Potting soil may contain a small amount of soil.
George

Kerrville, TX

Thanks geoz...

Conroe, TX(Zone 9a)

George, I've wondered about this myself. What are the (perceived) merits of a soilless mix, or one that does contain some soil?

Maggie

SE GA, GA(Zone 8a)

Soilless mixes have been sterilized and are generally used for seeding or small transplants that are being potted up because they are free of various organisms that cause damping off and other problems.

Aubrey

Temecula, CA(Zone 8b)

I've always been a little amused by the vocabulary in this matter. For most there is either Planting Mix/ Planter Mix or Potting soil.

Potting soils in this part of the country rarely...if ever...have any real earth in them and are almost always sterile unless specifically for outdoor use.

Planting/Planter Mixes are almost always a compost/ composted manure blended with raw or "nitrolized" wood products.

The confusion that ensues is often horrifying or disastrous for new/novice/ or beginner garderners and it's not exactly by accident. Too many secret handshakes in the gardening industry. I'm so glad for so many that Dave's Garden exists because it is a free exchange forum for information between experienced gardeners and for beginners.

It is wonderful to see how quickly replies were made to this question before a potential disaster of putting planter mix in a pot or potting soil in a hole happened.

DG rocks!!!

Conroe, TX(Zone 9a)

Amen!!

Cincinnati (Anderson, OH(Zone 6a)


Hi, everybody---one more followup question if you don't mind...

So then, if you are using something like Miracle Gro potting soil for containers, is it necessary to add more compost and amendments, etc. or are you supposed to use it as is? I know it has fertilizer in it good for three months already...

I'm thinking of for use in planting hostas or ordinary annuals...

thanks... t.

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.
BACK TO TOP