Photo by Melody

Comments regarding Johnny's Selected Seeds

Click here to return to Johnny's Selected Seeds's listing.

You are viewing only positive comments

  Feedback History and Summary  
304 positives
22 neutrals
35 negatives

Comments:

« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | ... 8 Next »

RatingAuthorContent
Positive yardener
(21 reviews)
On Mar 23, 2004, yardener Greenfield, OH (Zone 6a) wrote:

I received my order promptly and with instructions on the seed packet for achieving higher germination rates. I'm having well above average germination rate and I'm very thankful for the tip. Their selection and description in the catalog is tops.

Positive tinman04
(3 reviews)
On Mar 21, 2004, tinman04 Saint Marys, PA (Zone 5a) wrote:

I would recommend this company to anyone. Very positive experience. Friendly workers on the telephone, fast shipping and all the seeds I planted germinated.

Positive twitser
(15 reviews)
On Mar 7, 2004, twitser Dawsonville, GA wrote:

The seeds I ordered came quickly. Nice note on invoice. Lots of info on the seed packets which is a nice surprise for a novice like myself. Very pleased!

Positive mamajudy
(1 review)
On Feb 23, 2004, mamajudy Petersburg, TN wrote:

Have had a very positive experience in dealing with Johnny's. Customer Service Reps. extremely helpful and polite. Seeds received promptly.

Positive emolie
(2 reviews)
On Feb 21, 2004, emolie wrote:

Every order I have placed with Johnny's has been followed up with fantastic service. My order was shipped quickly, and completely, the packaging sturdy. Johnny's is the real deal. They really are farming up Maine, cultivating and maintaining great seed strains. While their catalog and website are simple, they are very effective. It is very rare to find a website that is able to keep realtime inventory, so it's no surprise that Johnny's doesn't have that function either. I will definitely order from them again and again.

Positive dthompso
(1 review)
On Feb 19, 2004, dthompso wrote:

I just managed to spend $40 at Johnny's on vegetable and flower seeds. I bought tomatoes, peppers, marigolds, impatiens, petunias sweet peas and sunflowers. They were super friendly on the phone and I'm really looking forward to getting my order.

Positive eve_s
(1 review)
On Dec 30, 2003, eve_s wrote:

Once again my order with Johnny's Selected Seeds was filled quickly and arrived before other orders I had placed earlier. It is this reliable service that keeps me coming back each year.

Positive joachim
(4 reviews)
On Dec 4, 2003, joachim wrote:

Thank you for preserving the only true Brandywine tomato (Suddath or Quisenberry strain), thank you for introducing Diva, one of the best tasting cucumbers ever and thank you for introducing some of the more exotic leafy greens. But maybe it is time to become the first honest seed supplier. Not every variety is great tasting, excellent, mouth watering etc. Most of your (and others) veggie varieties are mediocre and please, don't push them on novice gardeners.

Positive kmitchell
(3 reviews)
On Dec 2, 2003, kmitchell Amelia, OH wrote:

I ordered seeds last year from Johnny's. Great germination, fast service, (I ordered in Dec.) and good selection.

Positive Commonsense
(11 reviews)
On Nov 15, 2003, Commonsense Rock Hill, SC (Zone 7b) wrote:

I ordered their catalog from their website a week ago, and it arrived today. It is very impressive and the descriptions seem to be well-written and complete. I will be ordering from them in the spring. It is a pleasure to receive such a professional publication.


On March 8th, 2004, Commonsense added the following:

Their service is as professional as I would have expected. They confirmed my order immediately via e-mail, and they sent a separate e-mail telling me when it had been sent. My order arrived promptly. It was well-packaged and complete. I could not have a better opinion of them.

One question, though - isn't it illegal to sell opium poppy seeds for growing?
Positive pncowley
(2 reviews)
On Sep 1, 2003, pncowley wrote:

Just found the Garden Watchdog site, and thought I would post my experience with Johnny's Selected Seeds (JSS) here... not that another truly positive experience will have much impact.

I am a small fresh-market grower, and have used JSS as the sole seed source for everything except my tomatoes and peppers (I plant varieties not available through JSS) for the past two years, and across multiple orders. Each time, the order has been shipped quickly, with everything as advertised. I took a chance this year with some onion plants (I have always grown from sets or seed in the past) and they arrived in excellent condition, in perfect time for planting in my climate zone.

Even a late-season order received the same attention and immediate shipping that my earlier orders have received. (Their All-Star Gourmet lettuce mix has been such a hit at the local market that I ran short, and had to quickly replenish my stock).

And large quantities of seed are no problem, either! I highly recommend JSS as a seed and plant source.

Positive xplorer
(6 reviews)
On Aug 6, 2003, xplorer Makati, Amadeo,
Philippines wrote:

It's been great dealing with them. Whether the items are to be shipped to my mom in Virginia or to me in the Philippines, JSS delivers fast!

Positive bananabrain
(8 reviews)
On Jul 13, 2003, bananabrain wrote:

My seeds arrived post haste and everything I planted came up beautifully. Johnnies is Grade A Number 1!


On March 21st, 2004, bananabrain added the following:

I just got mroe seeds form Johnny's and once gain they're the best.
Positive jane99
(4 reviews)
On Jun 25, 2003, jane99 Collins, MO wrote:

I like ordering seeds from Johnny's because they give planting and germinating info in the catalog as well as on the seed pack. The info in the catalog is pretty detailed - i like that. Seeds arrived as scheduled - no complaints. peace & love,,,,,

Positive DonnaMack
(69 reviews)
On May 18, 2003, DonnaMack Elgin, IL (Zone 5a) wrote:

I am a three year customer of Johnny's. It took me a while to discover them, but they are great. I start hundreds of plants from seed annually, and JSS has very fresh, carefully wrapped seed with extremely high germination rates, with great, detailed instructons (such as ACCURATE time from planting to bloom - rare and very helpful). I grow both their excellent veggies (particularly fabulous lettuce I grow in pots), herbs (check out the gorgeous basils for ornamental use and seasoning) and flowers, an area they are rapidly expanding, coming up with neat exclusives (President Tyler Morning Glories, Salvis Gruppenblau). They have a wonderful ornamental grass selection (stipa, seteceum, pennisetum) a fabulous selection of salvias, and my favorite, ornamental broom corn (grows to seven feet tall in weeks, producing gorgeous tassels). Customer service is very responsive and concerned (I inadvertently double placed an order, which was corrected even before it hit my charge card!) I HIGHLY recommend them.

Positive M1stab
(3 reviews)
On May 17, 2003, M1stab wrote:

I know its surprising, but I, too, got excellent service from johnny's. They are among the best internet retail operations of any sort.

Positive shanstuff
(4 reviews)
On May 4, 2003, shanstuff Marietta, GA wrote:

My beans are already sprouting and looking very healthy and strong, and the lettuce is looking wonderful as well. Service was very prompt and professional, and prices were good.

Positive jenc
(8 reviews)
On Apr 15, 2003, jenc wrote:

Johnny's provides excellent quality seeds. They are fast, friendly, and helpful on the phone. They carry great garden tools as well. They have developed a few great seed strains - Bright Lights chard and tiny pumpkins. I love the wide range of vegetable and herb seeds available. Their flower range is expanding slowly.

Positive buggz
(3 reviews)
On Apr 11, 2003, buggz Peyton, CO (Zone 5b) wrote:

Johnny's offers great customer service, excellent variety, and high-quality products. I will definitely order from Johnny's again.

Positive enilniah
(7 reviews)
On Apr 8, 2003, enilniah Rockford, OH wrote:

prompt service and great seeds, will definately keep this company on my order list. seeds were here 3 days after I ordered from them.

Positive WVGrower
(6 reviews)
On Apr 4, 2003, WVGrower wrote:

I recently placed my first order with this company. The seeds arrived quickly and germination so far has been great. Made the mistake of planting several seeds in each pot and now have to thin!

Positive ccharikof
(3 reviews)
On Apr 4, 2003, ccharikof wrote:

I am very pleased with the service at Johnny's Seeds. Our order was shipped extremely fast and all the items were in stock. A very pleasant experience. I look forward to dealing with them again.

Positive puddlejumper
(2 reviews)
On Apr 3, 2003, puddlejumper wrote:

I've ordered from Johnnny's for many years. Their seed is extremely fresh and germination rates are excellent. That means I don't have to plant 3 seeds to get a single plant.
Their tomato varieties are limited but there are some great choices available. I wouldn't hesitate to order beans and corn and everything else from them, as this seed company pays close attention to taste as well as productivitiy.

Positive Imhotep
(26 reviews)
On Mar 24, 2003, Imhotep Meridian, MS wrote:

only ordered a few times in the past 4 - 6 years. I have
no complaints. varities are limited, but occasionally you
find something unique.

On a 1-10 scale I rate them a 9.

Positive Tedley
(3 reviews)
On Mar 11, 2003, Tedley wrote:

I ordered with Johnny's in late February and received my seeds in full in less than 7 days! When I called to inquire about the order their customer service was friendly and courteous and genuinely seemed to care. So far, all I've planted have been fresh and vigorous. I love all the unique varieties they have and also like their emphasis on organic production. Their resealable seed packets are a plus, too. I look forward to doing business with Johnny's in the future.

Positive ewaters
(7 reviews)
On Mar 7, 2003, ewaters wrote:

I ordered some echinacea seed from Johnny's and the very day the order arrived I received an offer of a $5.00 discount on my first order which I had already made. I emailed Johnny's to see if they would honor the $5.00 offer for the order that I had already made.They emailed me back promply saying that they would gladly refund me $5.00 on my order. Five dollars may not seem like a lot of money but the fact that they had the courtesy to respond to me and not brush me off was priceless. Johnny's is also the only company that I have seen so far that warns that to get most echinacea seeds to germinate they must be strafied. I then had to find out what stratified seeds were. In fact on further reading in their catalog they explain that stratification is the process of storing seeds at low temperatures in the refrigerator for about 30 days prior to planting. This process helps to break the dormancy inherent with echinacea seed. All this time I couldn't figure out why I could never get those seed to germinate.

Positive kaygarden
(2 reviews)
On Mar 3, 2003, kaygarden Crawfordsville, IN (Zone 5a) wrote:

I have been ordering from Johnnys for years. I always receive my seeds, etc. in a very timely manner. The seeds are always viable and grow well. I also like their focus on organic. Their help staff are always ver knowledgable and will spend all the time you need.

I will be a loyal Johhny's customer for many years to come!

Positive Griffitha
(2 reviews)
On Feb 26, 2003, Griffitha wrote:

The seeds were packaged nice. The instructions on planting was printed on 8 1/2 by 11 which made it easier to read. The prices was little higher than Pinetree Gardens but I thought they gave you more seeds with Johnny's.

Positive magic8ball
(5 reviews)
On Feb 23, 2003, magic8ball wrote:

The seeds I ordered arrived quickly. They did have a warning listed on the jalapeno seed package that the color would be paler than usual. I was impressed that they would inform the buyer of this. My faxed order was accidentally duplicated, which turned out not to be a problem. The order form is on legal size paper which doesn't fax properly sometimes. I would recommend phone or online ordering instead. They credited my account the next billing period, and all customer service reps were friendly and helpful. I have only planted the winter thyme seeds so far but they have already sprouted! I can't wait to see how the tomatoes and peppers do. Good experience so far!


On February 23rd, 2003, magic8ball added the following:

I forgot to mention that the company told me to keep the duplicated seed order instead of sending it back to them. I still got credited. Now that's good service.
Positive Pitch
(6 reviews)
On Feb 20, 2003, Pitch Port Washington, NY wrote:

My Cup and Saucer Vine seeds were receive three days after ordering, high germination rate. Looking foward to do business with again

Positive ddunbar
(2 reviews)
On Feb 10, 2003, ddunbar wrote:

I ordered over $300 of seeds from Johnny's. When my order arrived, they said I owed them more money. I checked my invoice and saw they had charged me $11.75 for something that was supposed to be $4.50. I called customer service. Indeed there had been a price increase. She apologized and suggested I send it back and request a refund on shipping. I did so. A week later, I got an envelope from them. It had MY ORIGINAL SEEDS in it, a letter of apology and a note stating they were sending me a check for $15.06; the cost of shipping for my seed order plus my refund. Now that's great customer service!!!!!!

Positive Sosa
(11 reviews)
On Jan 30, 2003, Sosa wrote:

Ordered a number of vegtable and herb seeds, they arrived in one week in good condition. Last years seeds all germinated well. My garlic was great! Very good catalog, selection, service, and growing info.

Positive elfeik
(32 reviews)
On Jan 27, 2003, elfeik Near Kansas City, MO (Zone 6a) wrote:

They are the best - all plant companies should copy their approach. I have had 99% success with there merchandise. For the few problems, they replaced the seeds with no quibble.

Positive ChicagoGardener
(5 reviews)
On Jan 27, 2003, ChicagoGardener Evanston, IL wrote:

This is a terrific company. Quality of their seeds is outstanding -- the germination rates I have had with with their seeds have been very high. Prices tend to be very competitive. Customer service is excellent -- not only can you get through, but they are friendly and responsive. The cultural information in the catalog is quite excellent and more extensive than for most catalogs. It is also a big plus that they are independent, and not part of one of the substantial corporate consolidation throughout the industry. Johnny's folksy email letter is down to earth and informative.

I can't say enough good things about my experience with Johnny's.

Positive shelly_mb
(1 review)
On Jan 14, 2003, shelly_mb wrote:

I recently recieved my 3rd order from Johnny's and have been nothing but pleased with there service. I especially like the information they provide regarding plant culture.

Shelly_mb
(master gardener)

Positive sgagnon
(1 review)
On Jan 10, 2003, sgagnon wrote:

I have been dealing with this company for over 10 years and have always enjoyed good quality seed and prompt and curtious service. I would highly reccomend them to anyone.

Positive WUVIE
(21 reviews)
On Jan 7, 2003, WUVIE Hulbert, OK (Zone 7a) wrote:

I have ordered from this company many times
and have always been absolutey nothing but thrilled
and happy about my purchases and seeds.
I will order from them again and again and again.


On February 9th, 2005, WUVIE added the following:

Recently when ordering, Johnny's reported they were out of several things on my 'want list'. Sadly, I strayed to another few companies. The transactions I experienced with these other companies left me running back to Johnny's with open arms.

When ordering on the telephone, they tell you right then if something is sold out, rather than waiting until you receive the order to discover such as I did with the unmentionables.
I would much rather select an alternate item than to shop elsewhere and wait for backorders. My apologies, Johnny's, you're back at the top of my list!

On March 9th, 2007, WUVIE added the following:

While I am shocked and surprised at the news that Johnny's has been affected by a scoundrel stealing website information, I do not feel it is necessary to post a negative.

The Watchdog is here for our experiences, good and bad. Unless our credit was ruined by the theft Johnny's experienced, I fail to see where our rating should be negative. It's like saying "You could have wrecked the car."
Could have. But didn't.

Yes, they were infiltrated in some way, but unless we were affected by such, it is not fair to post negative feedback for this company.

Every time we place an order on the internet we are taking a chance with a company. I've ordered from Johnny's numerous times and have yet to have one bad thing to say about their speed, service, quality of seed sold.

With regard to the comments about high prices, the prices are listed with the items. If the cost is too high, why buy? It isn't like we are surprised with a total, we are given the total when ordering. Where is the shock when the price tags are clearly supplied beforehand?

A happy Johnny's customer who was one of
the credit card folks.
Positive Produceman
(3 reviews)
On Jan 3, 2003, Produceman wrote:

Hi,

I have been ordering from Johnny's since I started gardening.
They have a great selection of seeds to choose from. I like how they get new varieties every year. I have ordered 45.00 of seeds last year and they all came up. If you are into gardening, I suggest Johnny's as a great start.

If you have any questions about this company email me at aaront@rmci.net

Positive CatskillKarma
(6 reviews)
On Dec 31, 2002, CatskillKarma West Kill, NY wrote:

I have been ordering from Johnny's for several years. Everything is exactly as advertised, with great selection. But, as a northern gardener, the thing I like best is that they prominently display days to maturity. About 90% of the seeds I order from other catalogs have problems reaching maturity in my short season. I never have to guess about this when I order from Johnny's.

« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | ... 8 Next »