Now I've got them straight!

Okay, this is Enchanted Princess...more pink than orangy

Quartzlight, while pinky is a much more delicate and petite bloom...

Concertina, besides being the tallest of the group, has that distinctive point to the beard and it's more of an orangy pink than a pinky orange if that makes sense...

Will post Chanted, which runs more peachy pink than pink, tomorrow for comparison.

Concertina is an IB (intermediate) which is why it is taller.

love those pinks.......

Chanted

Concertina on the left and Chanted on the right

If Concertina had looked that pink for me, I would definitely have kept it. Instead it was beige. Must be a climate thing...

Really a soil thing. It was soft pink here.

Do you think it needs a slightly acid soil?? I would love to get it as lost mine befire it bloomed but want pink not tan.

I have heavy clay soil and it is definitely pink for me, not tan or orange!

Sue - Taylorsville, KY Zone 6a

I would say my soil tended to be more acidic - definitely no clay here though.